RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Table 1 shows the characteristics of Rachenahalli Lake water quality; and Table 2 shows the characteristics of Amruthalli Lake Water quality.
TABLE 1 : Rachenahalli Lake Water Quality Results
I PHYSICAL PARAMETERS : |
PARAMETERS |
SAMPLE 1 |
SAMPLE 2 |
SAMPLE 3 |
SAMPLE 4 |
PH** |
7.2 |
7.65 |
7.95 |
7.54 |
ELECTRICAL CONDUCTIVITY* |
0.33 |
0.628 |
0.428 |
0.262 |
TEMPERATURE (oC) |
25.5 |
26 |
25 |
23 |
COLOUR** |
YELLOW |
YELLOW |
YELLOW |
YELLOW |
|
II CHEMICAL PARAMETERS: |
DISSOLVED OXYGEN |
2.3 |
4.5 |
4.8 |
7.5 |
ALKALINITY |
8.4 |
200 |
116 |
124 |
ACIDITY |
16 |
15 |
28 |
20 |
CHLORIDES |
70.98 |
175.9 |
173.94 |
83.98 |
TOTAL HARDNESS |
136.25 |
301.5 |
201.65 |
158.05 |
CALCIUM |
81.75 |
180 |
136.25 |
109 |
MAGNESIUM |
54.5 |
121.5 |
65.4 |
49.05 |
SODIUM |
29.24 |
55.78 |
42.52 |
27.01 |
POTASSIUM |
6.07 |
10.91 |
8.097 |
5.26 |
TOTAL SOLIDS |
352 |
580 |
584 |
332 |
TOTAL DISSOLVED SOLIDS |
296 |
510 |
512 |
285 |
TOTAL SUSPENDED SOLIDS |
56 |
70 |
72.4 |
47 |
SULPHATES |
23.8 |
23 |
37 |
31.94 |
NITRATES |
0.3107 |
0.3067 |
0.3016 |
0.2928 |
PHOSPHATES |
0.01 |
0.015 |
0.009 |
0.0085 |
TABLE 2 : Amruthalli Lake Water Quality Results
PARAMETERS |
SAMPLE 1 |
SAMPLE 2 |
SAMPLE 3 |
SAMPLE 4 |
I PHYSICAL PARAMETERS: |
PH ** |
7.46 |
6.7 |
6.9 |
6.87 |
ELECTRICAL CONDUCTIVITY* |
0.768 |
0.313 |
0.401 |
0.409 |
TEMPERATURE(oC) |
23 |
23 |
22.5 |
23.5 |
COLOUR** |
GREENISH |
GREENISH |
GREENISH |
GRENISH |
TRANSPARENCY(cm) |
NA |
NA |
NA |
NA |
|
II CHEMICAL PARAMETERS: |
DISSOLVED OXYGEN |
NIL |
NIL |
NIL |
NIL |
ALKALINITY |
350 |
195 |
190 |
175 |
ACIDITY |
45 |
55 |
55 |
60 |
CHLORIDES |
183.94 |
67.978 |
101.97 |
89.97 |
TOTAL HARDNESS |
392.4 |
218 |
205.75 |
201.65 |
CALCIUM |
250.7 |
130.8 |
125.75 |
119.9 |
MAGNESIUM |
141.7 |
87.2 |
80 |
81.78 |
SODIUM |
56.498 |
32.28 |
34.9 |
24.834 |
POTASSIUM |
9.163 |
6.378 |
5.45 |
5.5776 |
TOTAL SOLIDS |
718.88 |
404.44 |
398.2 |
446.66 |
TOTAL DISSOLVED SOLIDS |
644.44 |
340 |
342.7 |
342 |
TOTAL SUSPENDED SOLIDS |
74.44 |
64.44 |
55.5 |
104.6 |
SULPHATES |
61.95 |
26.89 |
23.12 |
23.39 |
NITRATES |
0.46 |
0.3599 |
0.451 |
0.488 |
PHOSPHATES |
0.2415 |
0.201 |
0.131 |
0.1975 |
* ms/cm, ** no unit, Rest denotes mg/l
unless Otherwise it is mentioned. |
Figure 1. and Figure 2. gives an idea about the water quality parameters value variation during different set of cycles in Rachenahalli and Amruthalli lakes respectively.
Fig.1. Rachenahalli lake water charecterstic variations during bio-monthly sampling
Fig.2. Amurthahalli lake water charecterstic variations during bio-monthly sampling
The analysis results shows that the Dissolved oxygen ranges from 2.3 to 8.2 mg/l in Rachenahalli lake and nil values in Amruthalli lake, Alkalinity ranges from 135 to 175 mg/l and 175 to 355 mg/l in Rachenahalli and Amruthalli lakes respectively, Total hardness ranges from 136 to 278 and 185 to 392 mg/l in Rachenahalli and Amruthalli lakes respectively, the Total suspended solids ranges from 6 mg/l to 92 mg/l in Rachenahalli lake and 31.4 to 150 mg/l in Amruthalli lake,the concentration of total phosphorous ranges from 0.0065mg/l to 0.0429 mg/l in Rachenahalli and 0.09 mg/l to 0.28 mg/l in Amruthalli lake and the Nitrate nitrogen concentration ranges from 0.10 mg/l to 0.333-mg/l and 0.204 mg/l to 0.488 mg/l in Rachenahalli and Amruthalli lakes respectively.
These results were compared with Indian Standard Specifications (NEERI) and Water quality datas of Sankey tank in Bangalore, collected during this period and that of Rachenahalli lake is slightly polluted by the parameters like nutrients, alkalinity and hardness, whereas Amruthalli lake is heavily polluted by nutrients, weed infestations, oxygen deficiency, odour, suspended solids, alkalinity and hardness, and has attained the eutrophic condition, as a results of urbanisation and various anthropogenic activities in the surrounding area.
Table 3 shows the economic dependency of the people residing closer to wetlands. The values are expressed in Rupees. Table 4 shows the valuation of Rachenahalli and Amruthalli lakes.
Table 3 : Socio-economic details
ITEMS |
Quantity of
Amruthalli
lake resources |
Amruthalli
lake value in Rs. |
Quantity of
Rachenahalli
lake resources |
Rachenahalli
lake value in Rs |
Domestic consumption |
277.9 lits/ house/day |
1.667/house/day |
214.97 lits/house/day |
1.289/house/day |
Livestock consumption |
59.28 lits/Cow/day |
35.5 /100 cows/day |
60.39 lits/cow/day |
36.18 /100 cows/day |
Agricultural consumption |
7201.02lits/Hectare/day |
43.19/hectare/day |
12087.8 lits/hectare/day |
72 /hectare/day |
Agricultural products: Paddy
Raggi
Flowers
Gowa
Vegetables
Coconut |
:15.1Q/ha/0.5year
:7.6Q/ha/0.5year
:3.95Q/ha/year
:74.23Q/ha/year
: --
:3000Nos./ha/yr |
21140/ha/0.5year
4560/ha/0.5year
11847.9/ha/year
37115/ha/year
---
11253/ha/year |
32.01Q/ha/year
12.5Q/ha/.05year
6.64/ha/year
60.1Q/ha/year
7.69Q/ha/year
5100.2Nos./ha/yr |
44814/ha/year
7500/ha/0.5year
19920/ha/year
30050/ha/year
10381.5/ha/year
19125/ha/year |
Energy resource |
0.47 Kg/person/day |
117.5/1000 |
1.298 Kg/person/day |
324.5/1000 persons/day |
Fishing products |
----- |
------- |
75 Kg./day |
900/day |
Table 4 : Valuation of Rachenahalli and Amruthalli lakes
Lake |
Direct use |
Indirect value |
Existence Vlue |
Use |
Value in
Rs. |
Rachenahalli |
*Agricultural
*Fuel
*Fish
*Livestock
consumption |
9173.0
324.5
900
37.5 |
*Ground water table varies from
50 (vicinity of lake)
250ft (at 2-3 km away from lake)
*It has greater capacity to retain
flood waters from heavy rainfall
and disposal of treated water
from JNCASR |
* birds and migratory birds
*Culture and heritage value.
*Pooja during festivals |
Result |
Total value is Rs. 10435
Per day, during Cropping
and fishing Season. |
Ground water recharge and flood
protection is increased due to
lakebed perviousness. |
Functional aspects, bio- diversity
and cultural, recreational aspectsindicates importance of wetland
eco system. |
Amruthalli |
Use |
Value in
Rs. |
*Ground water table varies from
180ft (vicinity of lake)
400ft(3 km away from the lake)
*It has lower flood protection value. |
*Existing lake has no culture,
heritage and biodiversity value |
*Fuel
*Livestock
consumption |
12.5
7.5 |
Result |
Total value is Rs. 20.0/day.
Lower value is due to eutrophic
condition of the lake which made
the wetland resources unusable |
It has no ground water recharge and
fewer flood control values mainly due
to impervious lakebed resulting from
the accumulation of silt. |
This is due to pollution on account
of anthropogenic activities in and
around the lake. |
The economic valuation is done to assess the dependency on wetlands. In the case of Rachenahalli lake by surrounding villages is estimated to be about Rs. 10,435/day ( during cropping and fishing season) and Amruthalli lake is about Rs.20.0/day. This shows that, the economic dependency in the case of Rachenahalli lake is more than that of people living around the Amruthalli lake due to better water quality and ecosystem. The ground water table of Rachenahalli lake ranges from 50 ft in the immediate vicinity and 250 ft at farther places (2-3 kms), while surrounding region of Amruthalli lake ground water table ranges from 180 - 400 ft. This is mainly due to, sediments accumulated in lake bed has become impervious which hinders recharging Sediment accumulation is due to siltation, which is a result of removal of vegetative cover in the catchment area. Apart from this, waste disposal in lake has resulted in eutrophic condition of the lake as consequence of urbanisation and industrialisation.
Bathymetric analysis confirmed sediment accumulation through reduction in depth and area (reduced considerably during last two decades). Water spread area has also declined due to encroachment f peripheral areas for agricultural purposes, settlements, construction of roads and institution etc.,