SECTION-8 Sustainable Water Resource Management, Policies And Protocols

RECLAMATION OF LAKES
T. Meenambal , S. Prabha1 and S.S. Vidhya1


ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
STUDY OF LAKES
LIGHT STRATIFICATION
THERMAL STRATIFICATION
PRODUCTIVITY STRATIFICATION:-OLIGOTROPHIC SERIES
EUTROPHIC SERIES
DYSTROPHY
SELF PURIFICATION PROCESS IN LAKES
PRACTICAL CONSIDERATION IN RECLAMATION
RECLAMATION METHODS
REDUCTION OF THE EXTERNAL LOADING
INTERVENTION IN THE LAKE ECOSYSTEM
AERATION OF WATER
DIVERSION OF HYPOLIMNIC WATER
PRECIPITATION OF PHOSPHORUS IN THE LAKE
REDUCTION OF BIOMASS CONCENTRATION
AERATION OF SEDIMENT
REMOVAL OF SEDIMENT
COVERING OF SEDIMENT
ADMISSION OF UNPOLLUTED WATER
CASE STUDY
USE OF RECLAIMED WATER:-DIRECT REUSE ABOVE GROUND
GROUND WATER RECHARGE
CONCLUSION
BIBLIOGRAPHY
FIGUES


ABSTRACT: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

The main objective of this paper is to bring out a suitable method for restoring lakes. The amount of fresh water on the earth is very small compared to seawater. Continued population growth and contamination of both surface and ground water due to effluent discharge from industries, uneven distribution of water resources and periodic droughts have forced water agencies to search for innovative sources of water supply. There is an urgent need for reclaiming the lakes. Some general comments on restoration methods are made and it is suggested that by diverting the discharge water and treating part of the lake water and using it as dilution water, an effective reclamation is possible. The reclaimed water can be used for various purposes.

INTRODUCTION: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

Inland waters cover less than 2% of the earth's surface and oceans (99%) cover 71% with an average depth of 3800m. Lake Baikal - the deepest lake in the world with a maximum depth of 1620m contains 20% of the earth's freshwater occupying a volume of 23,000 km2. The relatively small amount of water that occurs in freshwater lakes, have their basic importance in maintenance of terrestrial life. Freshwater supply is a serious problem in many parts of the world due to a number of factors as follows:

  • The distribution of human population is not related to the availability of water.
  • Urbanisation and industrialisation is concentrated in certain regions of the world where water consumption is as much as four times higher per unit area compared to other regions.
  • In areas where the rainfall/consumption ratio per unit area is lowest, water consumption is increasing exponentially. There is severe degradation of water quality in these areas due to pollution.
  • Freshwater must be reserved for other purposes such as recreation, transportation, fisheries, etc.
  • The impacts of overuse are changing and often distorting the ecological character of the lake. Commercial fish catching has declined due to pollution, over fishing, navigation and competition from the sports fishery. River that feeds the lake brings excess nutrients and toxins from industrial wastes and dredging activities. The pollution of lakes by toxic elements increases the depletion of available fresh water. The study of a lake and its importance is crucial when looking for restoration methods that will protect the lake from further pollution and reclaim it back to its natural state.

    STUDY OF LAKES: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Stratification of lakes is done based on light, heat and productivity.

    LIGHT STRATIFICATION: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Depending on the light penetrating the shallow lakes, they are classified as:

  • Littoral zone: Shallow water region with light penetration to the bottom, often occupied by rooted plants in natural lakes.
  • Profundal zone: The bottom and deep water area beyond the depth of effective light penetration. This zone is absent or very small in shallow lakes.
  • Limnetic zone: The open water zone to the depth of effective light penetration.
  • THERMAL STRATIFICATION: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Thermally lakes are divided into:

  • Epilimnion: Upper layer where warm water circulates.
  • Thermocline: Warm water circulating in the upper layer does not mix with the colder bottom water, creating a steep temperature gradient in between called thermocline.
  • Hypolimnion: Cold water in the bottom constitutes hypolimnion.
  • Mud
  • PRODUCTIVITY STRATIFICATION:
    OLIGOTROPHIC SERIES:
    first topic previous topic next topic last topic
    Hypolimnion is larger than the epilimnion. Eg. Alpine lakes.
    Littoral plants are scarce and the plankton density is low. Due to low productivity, the hypolimnion does not suffer from oxygen depletion and transparency is very high.

    EUTROPHIC SERIES: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    They are shallow lakes and littoral vegetation is abundant. Plankton concentration is more with low transparency.

    Trophic level refers to the organic matter in the lake. Depending on the organic matter the lake has been classified as below.

    DYSTROPHY: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Receiving large portion of the organic matter from external sources is called Dystrophy. Difference between dystrophy and eutrophy is the organic matter, allocthanous and autotropic respectively.

    SELF PURIFICATION PROCESS IN LAKES: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    There are different processes that take place in the lake such as photosynthesis, Carbon, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Silica and Sulphur cycles, etc., that help in self purification. Rivers get polluted by waste water discharged in to them. As the lakes get water from rivers, streams, precipitation etc, they get polluted with organic and inorganic wastes. As a result, the natural self purification process gets overburdened and disturbed, due to which a large amount of toxic substance remains in the lakes.

    PRACTICAL CONSIDERATION IN RECLAMATION: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Based on field experience, four conditions are necessary to justify construction of separate facilities for water reclamation.

  • Chemical quality of the water must be suitable for reuse.
  • Treatment has to be economically viable.
  • The quality of reclaimed water must be comparable to the standards specified depending on their end - use.
  • Reclaimable water must be produced near a project, which can utilize it.
  • RECLAMATION METHODS: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Restoration method is of two types:

  • Reduction of the external loading
  • Intervention in the lake ecosystem It is important that these two methods work in unison. Application of the second method will not be useful without the simultaneous reduction of the waste water discharge.
  • Reduction of the external loading
  • Intervention in the lake ecosystem It is important that these two methods work in unison. Application of the second method will not be useful without the simultaneous reduction of the waste water discharge.
  • REDUCTION OF THE EXTERNAL LOADING: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    A reduction of the external loading can be carried out by totally stopping the in flow of wastewater or diverting the waste water into another ecosystem like sea where the retention time is low. Wastewater containing nutrients such as phosphorus, nitrogen, etc can be diluted in the sea. Before that, a comprehensive study has to be made. With advanced waste water technology available these days, water treatment methods meet all the criteria.

    INTERVENTION IN THE LAKE ECOSYSTEM: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Methods under intervention of the lake ecosystem are:

  • Aeration of water
  • Diversity of hypolimnic water
  • Precipitation of phosphorus in the lake
  • Direct reduction of the biomass concentration in the lake
  • Aeration of sediment
  • Removal of sediment
  • Covering of sediment
  • Admission of unpolluted water
  • AERATION OF WATER: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Oxygen depletion occurs in the hypolimnion due to decomposition of organic matter. Oxygen concentration in lake water is of direct importance for all living organisms in the lake.

  • Ammonia, which is toxic to fish requires oxygen for nitrification
  • Increased concentration of phosphorus will accelerate photosynthesis, which will produce more organic matter requiring more oxygen for decomposition. This problem can be countered by aeration methods such as:
  • Destratification: Where cold hypolimnic water is pumped to the surface and mixed with epilimnic water.
  • Hypolimnic water is pumped to the surface, aerated with the atmosphere and transported back to the hypolimnion without mixing with the epilimnic water.
  • Aeration directly into the hypolimnion.
  • Destratification might in some cases have a negative effect on water quality due to high temperature at hypolimnion. The other two methods seem to reduce the hydrogen sulphide and phosphorus concentration and increase the oxygen concentration, while the direct effect on primary production is minimal.

    DIVERSION OF HYPOLIMNIC WATER: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Hypolimnic water is rich in nutrients and poor in oxygen. By diversion of hypolimnic layer with that of epilimnic water, nutrient and oxygen balance improves. But due to heat exchange there is some disadvantage.

  • Thermocline lowered - which might accelerate mineralisation process.
  • The nutrient rich hypolimnic water often with higher BOD5 may cause some pollution downstream.
  • PRECIPITATION OF PHOSPHORUS IN THE LAKE: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Phosphate can be precipitated by using aluminium sulphate, iron chloride or calcium hydroxide. Phosphate concentration is reduced after the addition of the precipitant but the effect is short lived. No further reduction in the primary production is observed concluding that chemical precipitation alone is inadequate. It is worth considering when used with other restoration methods.

    REDUCTION OF BIOMASS CONCENTRATION: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    In hyper-eutrophic lakes the production of biomass is many times faster than their consumption by grazing animals. By introducing herbivorous animals, it is possible to increase the grazing rate. For this method it is necessary that the oxygen concentration and pH - is good enough to allow the breeding of the introduced animals. Experience with this method is limited and it must be concluded that at its present stage, it is difficult to control.

    AERATION OF SEDIMENT: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Under aerobic conditions, the sediments are able to bind substantial amounts of phosphorus while under anaerobic conditions the sediments will release a significant part of phosphorus. The principles of sediment aeration are same as those described for aeration of hypolimnic water. The difference is whether aeration focuses on the oxygen concentration in the water or on the sediment surface.

    REMOVAL OF SEDIMENT: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Experience with removal of sediment shows an essential decrease of phosphorus concentration, reduction in algal growth, disappearance of blue-green algae and increase in transparency. It is necessary to take the entire phosphorus input into consideration when a restoration solution is being selected. This method is ideal, provided the total phosphorus input is reduced significantly. Unfortunately this method is expensive and is generally not applicable.

    COVERING OF SEDIMENT: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    Covering of sediment will prevent the release of nutrients in to the water body. Application of plastic sheets, fly ash, iron rich sand or clay has been suggested. The method is much cheaper than removal of the sediment, but has the following disadvantages:

  • The improvements are not permanent.
  • The natural conditions for the benthic fauna are altered.
  • ADMISSION OF UNPOLLUTED WATER: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    By addition of unpolluted water with low nutrient concentration to the lake, the lake water is diluted and the sediment is washed out. With decreased nutrient concentration, transparency increases and blue green algae disappears. This method must generally be considered attractive, but the admission of water might cause unacceptable changes in stratification due to difference in water temperature.

    CASE STUDY: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    As seen above no single method can be used effectively in reclamation of lakes. With the combination of precipitation and diversion of the waste water, a better reclamation method can be established. Considering the precipitation method, a pilot pond is constructed with shallow depth, to avoid bloom of zooplanktons, and stocked with fish. Presence of such zooplankton predators is necessary for achieving a stable ecosystem. Growth of phytoplankton makes nitrogen a growth limiting factor. Algae can be separated from the effluent by coagulation with alum followed by either sedimentation or filtration. Reduction of phosphorus and nitrogen concentration (by precipitation) could be brought to 39% and 30% respectively. Effective algal separation could be brought using alum when the concentration of phosphorus is reduced (91 to 93%). Water from the lake is diverted to the pilot pond for purification and then returned to the lake. The thermal stratification is not altered. This has been effected in Lake Washington where the lake has started getting back to its original state. After few years, the nutrient concentration in the lake will be highly reduced by the pilot pond. Any addition of polluted water with less nutrient will be purified by the lake's self-purification mechanism.

    USE OF RECLAIMED WATER:
    DIRECT REUSE ABOVE GROUND
    first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    1. Industry
    2. Aquaculture
    3. Recreational activities

    GROUND WATER RECHARGE first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    1. Surface spreading
    2. Direct injection into aquifers
    3. Over irrigation of crops
    4. Sub surface percolation systems

    CONCLUSION: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

    This restoration method has been carried out without altering the lake's own stratification so that the reclamation of lakes can be effectively achieved.

    BIBLIOGRAPHY: first topic previous topic next topic last topic

  • Airaksinen, J.Y. Improvement of the quality of waste pond effluents in northern areas by chemical pre-precipitation. Water pollution research. Edited by S.H. Jenkins.
  • Nyholm, N, Sorensen, P.E., Olrik, K and Pedersen, S.D. Restoration of lake - Nakskor idrefjord, Denmark, Using algal ponds to remove nutrients from inflowing river water. Water pollution research. Edited by S.H. Jenkins. pp.881.
  • Puffer, W.R. Assessment of aqua culture for reclamation of waste water. Water reuse edited by E. Joe Middle Brooks, pp.349.
  • FIGURES first topic previous topic next topic last topic



    ADDRESS first topic previous topic

    1.) Department of Environmental Engineering,
    Government College of Technology,
    Coimbatore - 641 013